BIAL sham
By SVAKSHA on 2008 May 28 [Wednesday], 08:32:00 - INDIA - Permalink
On Sunday, we went to drop MA and also to check out the BIAL airport in Devanahalli, only to find there is nothing international about it. If you are expecting another Changi, Heathrow, O'Hare or a JFK, hold your breath --- Its not even a patch on any of them, which is self-evident when you are confronted with a very smallish glass and concrete structure standing in the middle of nowhere with construction debris strewn all around for company.
For an idea of how BIG this structure is :: on the outside, you can walk from one end (departure) of this small structure to the other end (arrival) in 10 minutes flat (It being a Sunday the place was swarming in the evening with curious on-lookers with families in tow to gawk at the nondescript airport in no-mans' land).
[UPDATE1 : the 10 min is walking outside the building only, from the time you alight at the bus-stand to the arrival area, and not the time taken to alight a flight and exit with luggage in tow. Minus the Sat/Sunday on-lookers it should hardly take 5 min and less than that with no luggage. That is how small the international structure is.]
Last year when HU had come over and visited the construction site at devanahalli, i went along out of sheer curiosity. Being a weekday and peak traffic time to boot, it took 2.5 hours just to reach devanahalli. We entered via the runway and speeding on the parallel service track was sheer fun. I imagine the runway would be an F1 track (*grin*) which they ought to be. We climbed the ATC tower, got the obligatory snaps, and midway DA got bored and tired of all the exposure in the hot sun, wanted to leave asap (imagine 2 women in a construction site and you know why). I had seen the terminal then and thought there would be a separate one for international flights atleast. On Sunday, 2008May25 I realised i was wrong.
Let's start again... For a late evening flight (8pm'ish) we left home at 4pm
and trudged to the nearest bus-stand, luggage et al. Yeah, driving raises my
blood pressure and i dont own a 4-wheeler. So what used to be a
hop-skip-and-jump to the airport in 15 min by auto, is now a torturous 2 hour
fuel-guzzling environment polluting 50km unnecessary ride. I like to
receive/drop my friends and family to the station/airport/bus-stand when ever
they come over. That will soon change atleast as far as the airport is
concerned. There are 9
bus-stands and it takes 2 hours to get there, not including the time spent
idling waiting for the bus to start or the time taken to get to the bus
station.
We got talking to the conductor and he said the Majestic Volvo route makes 30,000 rupees per day and other routes too get good earnings. The fares are steep -- Volvo AC bus is 150 bucks single fare one-way and a bmtc bus costs 80 bucks one-way --when you compare the same volvo AC bus from Chennai Central Train station to Tiruvanmiyur (around 25 km) costs just 25 rupees, yeah just 25 bucks ! So do the Bangalore Volvo buses have special wings that they charge three times the amount for the same distance???
The bus conductors are made to do 24 hours duty but only get paid 4 hours over-time on the basic pay and get one day off .... so they work 4 days a week 24 hours at a stretch, which seems harsh.
From the bus-station to the swanky small structure is a distance of a
quarter kilometer and if it rains, which is all the time in bangalore, be
prepared to get drenched. There are no rest rooms for those who come to see-off
their kith and kin...there is one half a km away and if you are hungry of
thirsty be prepared to shell out more than 50 bucks for a bottle of
water.
[Addendum : Private taxis charge Rs 950-1000/- for a single
journey. If you are wondering why they charge you the return fare, its coz they
claim they have to make the return journey to the city with no passengers hence
you will pay them for a journey you dont make.]
Once inside the airport its chaos, the ground-staff dont belong to the individual airlines, rather they are all contracted employees by BIAL who have not been adequately trained on how to use the computer, printer, and check-in passengers. To their credit they are polite but heck that does not stop the confusion with long queues and irritated passengers left holding confirmed tickets with no flights to board....not nice.
The inside is not very impressive nor is it spacious and departures are on the second level -- local flights to the left and international flights to the right (empty when we were there). After security check tons of floor space has been devoted to malls and shops ...you name the brand and its there. So it does seem that in all this, apparently only the promoters seem to benefit financially at the expense of the tax-paying public, money** is being thrown to the winds. After all the so-called glowing reports the reality is slowly seeping out.
[** User development fee/toll/service fee, call it whatever you like but the user (common citizens) should not have to pay ridiculous prices/fees for airport related services had the government done an iota of city planning. Instad they give away 4000 acres of real estate almost for free to a private company which is the sole beneficiary, not the government. In what way is the government earning? -- Taxes ? No, ...then its lost earnings and indirectly a waste of public money (read 4000 acres of land).]
Comments
Lucky that you got a chance to drive on thr runway before BIAL became operational. I'm sure only a few people have got a chance to do that. True, it takes 10 mins from the flight to walk out of the terminal building, but world over, thats exactly what people call a "good" airport! how short a time it takes from entrace to aircraft and vice versa.
Also, the promoters aren't making money off the tax paying public, the money was raised for the airport BY the promoters. Visit http://www.bengaluruairport.com/portal/page/portal/BIAL_PageGroup/BIAL_ABOUT_HOME/10_BIAL_ABOUT_BIAL/11_BIAL_ABT_ABOUT_SHAREHOLDERS for more information.
I think for ONCE, lets just be positive about Bangalore's new airport!
@Monica : not the runway --which always has a parallel road where vehicles are allowed and i heard many folks were allowed. This is a private enterprise after all. The 10min i was talking about is not the time taken to alight the flight and walk out the arrivals. Rather its walking outside the building, from the time you alight at the bus-stand to the arrival area. That is how small the international structure is.
HAL airport was convenient for a lot of people but a large airport cannot exist in the middle of the city. Too much noise, pollution and traffic. I know there is a debate to keep it open for small aircraft and I am not going to go in to it.
FYI
The government did not give the land for free. It got 26% share (13% for AAI and 13% for GoK) of BIAL. Not if that 26% is equivalent to the value of the land is up to experts to analyze. So the government earns dividends and on service tax charged on all of the services provided in the airport.
I am no apologist for BIAL but any new airport will have teething troubles and if the management is good should get resolved in the coming weeks. Though there are other capacity issues with the airport that all would like to see how it is played out.
I'm now more curious than ever to see what is actually, whether it lives up to the hype that surrounds it and the like. I had interacted with the chief engineer from the Indian ops side and he was a pretty straightforward man. He had managed to rub the short-sighted local authorites the wrong way by going ahead with the construction work without waiting for any political big-wig to cut the ribbon! Just that one bit of info made me think that all is not yet lost.
By the way, i'm the Prashanth that you met at the Linux Chix bof at FOSS.in.
@pura :: just coz the gov has X% does not mean it will get X% of revenue earned... actual earnings are very different if you look deeper at financial structure as the revenue stream is dependent on the agreement terms and clauses they entered in the contract. You may have seen cases in India where companies get away with financial fraud.
@prashanth :: in most cases when there is private participation the common man is treated better but in this case 'money making' seems to be the core objective. They have not even bothered to keep chairs for people to sit outside, the rest-rooms are located a mile away and so on... the worst is the amount of fuel and time that will be wasted in traveling 50kms to the airport and 50km to return home, especially with rising Oil prices
TBH, its a
complete lack of city-planning from the gov side and apathy from the
citizens.
Dear Vid,
Thank you for your interest in Bengaluru International Airport. Your comments and feedback are appreciated, we will use them to improve our services. If you have any queries on the airport do feel free to get in touch with us.
Regards,
BIAL Communications team